Private prison company leaving Idaho
Decision came as Idaho State Police is investigating allegations of possible contract fraud and falsified staffing reports involving CCA
By Rebecca Boone
BOISE, Idaho — Private prison giant Corrections Corp. of America will leave Idaho after more than a decade marked by scandal and lawsuits surrounding its operation of the state's largest prison.
The Nashville, Tenn.-based company will not bid on the next contract to run the Idaho Correctional Center south of Boise, CCA Vice President Brad Regens said in a letter Thursday to the Department of Corrections.
The decision came as Idaho State Police, aided by a forensic auditing firm, is investigating allegations of possible contract fraud and falsified staffing reports involving CCA.
A federal judge also has held CCA in contempt of court for failing to abide by the terms of a settlement agreement reached with inmates in a lawsuit claiming high rates of violence and chronic understaffing at the prison.
CCA spokesman Steven Owen said the company is taking appropriate steps to remedy staffing problems at the prison and is committed to reimbursing taxpayers for any unverified hours.
CCA's contract with Idaho ends on June 30, 2014.
"We have delivered exceptional value to Idaho's taxpayers through cost savings, and we've also provided outstanding rehabilitation programming to the inmates entrusted in our care," Regens wrote in the letter.
It's not clear, however, whether Idaho's $29 million contract with CCA represented an actual cost savings. An investigation by The Associated Press in 2012 showed it would likely cost the Idaho Department of Corrections the same amount of money or less to have state employees run the facility.
Idaho Department of Correction Director Brent Reinke has asked the state Board of Correction at least twice if his department should examine whether it would be cheaper for the state to run the prison, but both times he was rebuffed.
The Idaho Board of Correction had the option to extend CCA's contract for two more years but decided in June against it. Instead, the state will issue a formal request for proposals later this year.
At the time, the board didn't rule out the possibility that it would select CCA to run the prison under a new contract.
Regens, however, said the company does not intend to submit a proposal.
"We will focus our efforts during the remainder of the contract term on ensuring the facility continues to operate in a safe and secure manner," he said in the Wednesday letter. "We will work closely with the department to ensure a smooth and orderly transition."
CCA has acknowledged that its employees filed staffing reports with the state that incorrectly showed it had the contractually required number of guards on duty during several months in 2012.
Owen, the company's spokesman, said the unverified hours were only a fraction of total staffing requirements at the prison. The company has maintained that the understaffing did not result in an increase of violence or any security problems at the prison.
"We are working day in and day out in the facility to make sure what happened never happens again," Owen said in an email to The Associated Press. "If a post cannot be filled there is a process to document what steps were taken to fill it and, if it couldn't be filled, what was done to address the impact of the vacancy."
CCA officials didn't rule out a possible return to Idaho. The letter said CCA "looks forward to the opportunity to serve the department in the future."
Monica Hopkins, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Idaho, said she was glad to hear CCA was leaving the state after several years of litigation and the federal judge's ruling holding the company in contempt.
"Unfortunately the state hasn't realized that it's time to take back ownership and operation of their own facility, so there's no guarantee that this won't happen with another private contractor," Hopkins said. "CCA was bad for Idaho. It was detrimental for the taxpayers. And it's time for the state to exercise the proper role of government and operate its own facilities."
Boise attorney T.J. Angstman, who is representing inmates in an ongoing lawsuit alleging CCA ceded control to prison gangs so it could operate the facility with a skeleton crew of guards, said the departure won't automatically fix the problems at the prison.
"CCA is going to leave the cleanup and aftermath of those problems to somebody else," Angstman said. "Likely it will cost the state more money to find a new contractor, because somebody's going to have to pay more money to fix the problems."
CCA has denied the allegations in the lawsuit from Angstman's firm. Owen has said the company's top priority is the safety of inmates and employees.
Copyright Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.